- 9 to 5 the Musical – Winter 2014
- 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee, The – Winter 2016
- 1776 – Spring 1975
- 1940’s Radio Hour, The – Winter 1989
- 1940’s Radio Hour, The – Winter 2000
- A…My Name Will Always Be Alice – Winter 2011
- Addams Family, The – Fall 2016
- Aladdin and His Wonderful, Magical Lamp – Summer 2003 (youth)
- All Night Strut, The – Winter 1992
- Annie – Fall 1985
- Annie – Spring 1996
- Annie Get Your Gun – Fall 1961
- Annie Get Your Gun – Fall 1977
- Annie Get Your Gun – Spring 2005
- Annie Jr. – Summer 2015 (Youth)
- Annie Warbucks – Fall 1998
- Anything Goes – Spring 1985
- Anything Goes – Summer 2023 (Teen)
- Applause – Spring 1975
- Beauty and the Beast, Disney’s – March 2019
- Bells Are Ringing – Spring 1970
- Best Little Whorehouse in Texas, The – Spring 2017
- Big Bad Musical, The – Summer 2018 (Children’s)
- Big Fish – Spring 2015
- Big, The Musical – Spring 2002
- Blame It on the Movies! – Winter 1998
- Blood Brothers – Winter 2004
- Bridges of Madison County, The – Winter 2022
- Brigadoon – Fall 1957
- Bright Star – Winter 2020
- Bugsy Malone Jr. – Summer 2007 (youth)
- Butler Did It, Singing, The – Winter 1993
- Bye Bye Birdie – Fall 1968
- Bye Bye Birdie – Fall 1986
- Cabaret – Winter 2009
- Calamity Jane – Spring 1964
- Camelot – Fall 1966
- Camelot – Fall 1982
- Carousel – Fall 1962
- Carousel – Spring 1978
- Charlotte’s Web – Summer 1998 (youth)
- Chicago – Fall 2005
- Christmas Story, A – Fall 2023
- Cinderella – Spring 2006
- Cinderella, Rodgers + Hammerstein’s – Summer 2022 (Teen)
- Civil War, The – Fall 2009
- Coffeehouse Mainstage Edition: Evolution of Broadway – Winter 2024
- Cole – Winter 1986
- Connecticut Yankee, A – Spring 1957
- Curtains – Winter 2018
- Dames at Sea – Fall 1995
- Damn Yankees – Spring 1984
- Damn Yankees – Spring 1999
- Day in Hollywood/A Night in the Ukraine, A – Winter 1990
- Descendants: The Musical, Disney’s – Summer 2022 (Children’s)
- Desert Song, The – Spring 1962
- Dirty Rotten Scoundrels – Spring 2011
- Disney’s Beauty and the Beast – March 2019
- Disney’s Descendants: The Musical – Summer 2022 (Children’s)
- Disney’s Finding Nemo Jr. – Summer 2024 (Children’s)
- Disney’s Frozen Jr. – Summer 2021 (Children’s)
- Disney’s High School Musical – Summer 2018 (Teen)
- Disney’s The Lion King Jr. – Summer 2023 (Children’s)
- Disney’s The Little Mermaid – Fall 2017
- Do Black Patent Leather Shoes Really Reflect Up? – Spring 1989
- Do Black Patent Leather Shoes Really Reflect Up? – Spring 2009
- Elf the Musical – Fall 2021
- Enchanted Sleeping Beauty – Summer 2001 (youth)
- Enchantment of Beauty and the Beast, The – Summer 1999 (youth)
- Evening with the Music of Andrew Lloyd Webber, An – Fundraiser 2007
- Evolution of Broadway – Winter 2024
- Fantasticks, The – Winter 2005
- Fiddler on the Roof – Fall 1971
- Fiddler on the Roof – Fall 1997
- Finding Nemo Jr., Disney’s – Summer 2024 (Children’s)
- Flapper – Summer 2009 (youth)
- Footloose – Summer 2017 (Teen Musical)
- Forever Plaid – Winter 2001
- Frozen Jr., Disney’s – Summer 2021 (Children’s)
- Funny Girl – Spring 1973
- Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum, A – Spring 1981
- Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum, A – Fall 1993
- Genesis: The Creation Story – December 1984
- Ghost the Musical – Winter 2023
- Godspell – Spring 1998
- Godspell – Spring 2024
- Grease – Fall 1996
- Grease – Summer 2016 (Teen Musical)
- Great American Trailer Park Musical, The – Winter 2013
- Great Ghost Chase, The – Summer 2002 (youth)
- Guys and Dolls – Spring 1967
- Guys and Dolls – Fall 2014
- Gypsy – Fall 1975
- Gypsy – Spring 2012
- Hairspray – Summer 2021 (Teen)
- Hans Christian Andersen – Summer 1982 (Youth)
- Hello, Dolly! – Spring 1971
- Hello, Dolly! – Fall 2010
- High School Musical, Disney’s – Summer 2018 (Teen)
- HONK! Jr. – Summer 2006 (youth)
- How to Succeed in Business without Really Trying – Spring 1983
- How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying – Fall 2001
- Hunchback of Notre Dame, The – Fall 2022
- Jack and the Giant – Summer 1993 (youth)
- James and the Giant Peach Jr. – Summer 2017 (Children’s)
- Jekyll & Hyde – Fall 2007
- Jerry’s Girls – Winter 1996
- Jesus Christ Superstar – Spring 2004
- John & Jen – Winter 2019
- Kilroy Was Here! – Summer 2004 (youth)
- King and I, The – Fall 1965
- King and I, The – Spring 1980
- King and I, The – Fall 2003
- Kismet – Fall 1963
- Kiss Me Kate – Spring 1969
- La Cage Aux Folles – Winter 2015
- Leader of the Pack – Winter 1999
- Les Misérables – Spring 2014
- Li’l Abner – Fall 1967
- Lion King Jr., Disney’s The – Summer 2023 (Children’s)
- Little Mermaid, The – Summer 1995 (youth)
- Little Mermaid, Disney’s The – Fall 2017
- Little Night Music, A – Winter 2012
- Little Princess, A – Summer 2011 (youth)
- Little Shop of Horrors – Spring 1990
- Little Shop of Horrors – Spring 2016
- Mad Adventures of Mr. Toad, The – Summer 2008 (youth)
- Mame – Spring 1972
- Mamma Mia! – Spring 2022
- Man of La Mancha – Spring 1993
- Marry Me a Little – Spring 1988
- Meet Me in St. Louis – Fall 1992
- Meet Me in St. Louis – Fall 2018
- Merry Widow, The – Spring 1956
- Music Man, The – Spring 1963
- Music Man, The – Spring 1977
- Music Man, The – Fall 1990
- Music Man, The – Spring 2008
- My Fair Lady – Spring 1976
- My Fair Lady – Fall 2008
- My One and Only – Spring 1991
- Of Thee I Sing – Spring 1960
- Oh, Coward! – Winter 1983
- Oklahoma! – Fall 1959
- Oliver! – Fall 1976
- Oliver! – Fall 1994
- Oliver! – Fall 2012
- On a Clear Day You Can See Forever – Fall 1969
- On the Other Side of the Fence – Summer 2012 (youth)
- Once on This Island Jr. – Summer 2014 (youth)
- Once Upon a Mattress – Fall 1978
- Once Upon a Mattress – Spring 1997
- Oz! – Summer 2000 (youth)
- Pajama Game, The – Spring 1965
- Pajama Game, The – Spring 1982
- Pippin – Winter 2003
- Pippin – Summer 2024 (Teen)
- Pirates of Penzance – Fall 1987
- Pretzels – Winter 1987
- Promises, Promises – Spring 2013
- Pump Boys and Dinettes – Winter 1991
- Ragtime – Fall 2006
- Ransom of Red Chief, The – Summer 1997 (youth)
- Red Mill – Spring 1961
- RENT – Fall 2013
- Return of Halley’s Comet, The – Summer 2013 (youth)
- Rodgers + Hammerstein’s Cinderella – Summer 2022 (Teen)
- Rodgers & Hart: A Celebration – Winter 1995
- Ruthless! – Winter 2008
- School House Rock Live! – Spring 2001
- Secret Garden, The – Spring 2010
- Seussical – Spring 2023
- Seven Brides for Seven Brothers – Fall 1989
- She Loves Me – Spring 1987
- Shenandoah – Fall 1984
- Shenandoah – Spring 2003
- Show Boat – Fall 1958
- Show Boat – Spring 1968
- Shrek the Musical – Fall 2015
- Singin’ in the Rain – Fall 1991
- Sister Act – Spring 2018
- Sister Amnesia’s Country Western Nunsense Jamboree – Spring 2000
- Sleepy Hollow – Summer 2005 (youth)
- Smoke on the Mountain – Winter 1997
- Some Enchanted Evening – Winter 1985
- Something’s Afoot – Winter 1988
- Sound of Music, The – Fall 1964
- Sound of Music, The – Fall 1980
- South Pacific – Fall 1960
- South Pacific – Fall 1974
- South Pacific – Fall 2004
- Spitfire Grill, The – Winter 2010
- State Fair – Fall 2000
- Student Prince, The – Spring 1966
- Sugar – Spring 1979
- Sugar – Fall 2002
- Sugar Babies – Fall 1988
- Sugar Babies – Fall 1999
- Sweeney Todd – Fall 2011
- Take Me Along – Fall 1973
- They’re Playing Our Song – Fall 1983
- Two By Two – Spring 1974
- Two by Two – Spring 1994